Do you go to the dungeon?

Papazotl's Petting Zoo

In regards to Papazotl's Riddle the statues with animal heads are as following:

Standing with the double doors in your back looking into a rectangular chamber there are six human-like statues with animals heads recessed into the wall. Three on the left side and three on the other.

Position (from left) What animal head?
1st Lizard
2nd Jaguar
3rd Lobster
4th Toucan
5th Bat*
6th Frog

* When light shined upon it revealed a secret door behind it leading to another puzzle piece. Might be referencing Papazotl's Riddle first part:

COMES WITH SUNSHINE
LEAVES WITH NIGHT